When Louisville sellers compare a cash offer vs. a realtor, they almost always compare the wrong numbers. A $250,000 listing price and a $205,000 cash offer look like a $45,000 gap - but that comparison ignores commissions, closing costs, repair spending, and months of holding costs that come out of the listing side before you ever see a check. Once you run the actual net-proceeds math, the gap is usually much smaller than it first appears, and sometimes it disappears entirely. Here's how to do that math for your own house.
Step 1: Start with a realistic sale price, not a hopeful one
Pull recent comparable sales for your street or neighborhood, not the highest listing you've seen on Zillow. Louisville's market varies block by block - a fully updated home in St. Matthews sells very differently than a similar-sized house needing work in Portland or California neighborhood. Be honest about condition, because an inflated estimate will throw off every number that follows.
Step 2: Subtract the traditional-sale costs, one by one
- Agent commissions: typically around 5-6% of the sale price, split between listing and buyer's agents. On a $250,000 sale, that's $12,500-$15,000 gone before anything else.
- Seller-paid closing costs: title fees, transfer tax, attorney fees, and often a buyer concession toward their closing costs, commonly another 1-3% ($2,500-$7,500).
- Pre-listing repairs: most agents will recommend fixing the roof, HVAC, or cosmetic issues before listing to attract full-price offers. Depending on the house, this can run anywhere from a few thousand dollars to $30,000+.
- Holding costs while it sits on market: mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, and utilities don't stop while you wait for a buyer. In Louisville, homes needing work can sit 60-120 days before an accepted offer, then another 30-45 days to close - that's often three to five months of carrying costs.
- Post-inspection negotiations: financed buyers almost always ask for repair credits or price reductions after their inspection, which chips away at your accepted offer price again.
Add all of that up against a $250,000 hoped-for price, and it's common to see $40,000-$60,000 in total costs and reductions by the time you actually close - which is very close to, or sometimes below, what a straightforward cash offer would net you today, without the wait.
A worked example
- Estimated listing price: $250,000
- Agent commissions (6%): -$15,000
- Seller-paid closing costs (2%): -$5,000
- Pre-listing repairs (roof, HVAC, paint): -$18,000
- Holding costs over 4 months on market: -$6,000
- Post-inspection credit negotiated by buyer: -$4,000
Net proceeds from the traditional sale: $202,000. If a local cash buyer offered $195,000 with no repairs, no commissions, and a close in 7-10 days instead of 4-6 months, the actual gap is only about $7,000 - and that gap shrinks further once you factor in the value of not living through months of showings, uncertainty, and carrying costs.
The headline sale price is never the number that lands in your bank account. Net proceeds - what's left after every cost is paid - is the only number worth comparing.
When listing with a realtor still wins
If your house is already in excellent, move-in-ready condition and you're not in a hurry, a traditional listing will usually net more money, because you're not paying for repairs you don't need and the house should sell relatively quickly at close to asking price. Read our full breakdown of every option for selling fast in Louisville to see where your situation fits before committing to either path.
When a cash offer wins
A cash offer tends to win the math when your house needs real repairs, you can't afford to carry a mortgage for several more months, or you're dealing with a time-sensitive situation like a job relocation, a foreclosure timeline (see our guide on how to avoid foreclosure in Louisville, KY), or an inherited property you'd rather not manage. Understanding exactly how cash offers are calculated will help you judge whether a given offer is fair before comparing it against your listing math.
Run your own numbers before deciding
Every house is different, and this article is meant to walk you through the process, not replace it - for tax or legal questions about your specific sale, consult a real estate attorney or CPA. But for most sellers, the exercise of actually writing out both columns side by side, rather than comparing headline numbers, is the single most useful thing you can do before deciding how to sell.
Get a real number to compare against
Want an actual cash offer to run against your own net-proceeds math instead of guessing? Call the Your Local Home Buyer Team at (502) 660-8782 for a no-obligation cash offer within 24 hours, with a close in 7-10 days if you decide it's the better fit.
Want a real number on your house?
Your Local Home Buyer, LLC buys houses as-is across Louisville and Southern Indiana. Get a no-obligation cash offer within 24 hours.